:::
:::
2025/09/09Events

【Law vs. Medicine】Legal Lecture – NHI Fraud: Identifying Common Types of Improper Claims

 

Cross-disciplinary exchange between law and medicine has entered its third year. Coinciding with the opening of the Taipei Medical Association’s new premises, President Hung De-jen arranged for this session to be held in the conference room of the new premises. The opening of this conference room signals that the dialogue between medicine and law has deepened from early public advocacy into a regular, institutionalized platform for communication, reflecting the medical community’s long-term commitment to legal compliance and professional resilience.

〔照片 1〕

The moderator, Dr. Chou Nai-Kuan, Chairperson of the Foundation, noted that with advances in medical technology, organ donation practice has made significant breakthroughs, and there are now many clinical examples of elderly donors successfully donating kidneys to recipients. Yet such acts of altruism must still be firmly grounded in medical ethics and the legal framework as a foundation of trust, so as to build a sustainable and sound healthcare environment.

The distinguished guest, President Chen Tsung-Chen of the Chinese Society of Law, shared the practical difficulties posed by the caseload in the justice system, in which fraud cases are especially prominent. President Chen pointed out that daily fraud losses across Taiwan approach NT$300 million, and that judicial authorities must handle more than 160,000 fraud cases a year; the sheer volume of case files has directly contributed to the departure of experienced judges and prosecutors. On the medical side, National Health Insurance (NHI) resources are constrained by the global budget system, and resource shortages and fluctuating point values likewise test the operational resilience of medical institutions. Any improper NHI claims or fraudulent collection of payments not only weakens the overall NHI budget, but also directly erodes the point values allocated to other, compliant medical professionals, and may even indirectly cause recruitment difficulties at leading medical institutions.

Executive Director Chou Hsien-Chang of the Taipei Medical Association also gave a detailed analysis of Article 81 of the National Health Insurance Act, which bears directly on practicing physicians, together with practical experience, and explained that the medical association has put in place professional personnel and resources to provide members with practical and effective support.

The Legal Framework for NHI Claims and Practical Warning Signs

Under Article 81 of the National Health Insurance Act and related regulations, violations by medical institutions may lead to administrative fines, criminal liability, and suspension of contracts under the management regulations (for example, cases involving claims under a borrowed license, fabricated records, or allowing unqualified personnel to work may result in contract suspension of one to three months). The six core types of violations currently targeted by the National Health Insurance Administration are:

  • Allowing unqualified persons to practice: hiring unlicensed or unqualified persons to perform nursing duties.
  • Fabricating medical visits: claiming without any actual treatment, creating medical records, or swiping one NHI card multiple times.
  • Improper release of prescriptions: circumventing the separation of prescribing and dispensing to split and collect pharmacy service fees improperly.
  • Billing self-paid items to the NHI: claiming self-paid items such as orthokeratology lenses or advanced health checkups under disease diagnoses.
  • Improper drug claims: claiming high-priced drugs inconsistent with the patient’s condition, or profiting from drug price differences.
  • Identity fraud: using another person’s NHI card or personal data to file false claims.

Any administrative shortcut may trigger both administrative and criminal liability, with knock-on effects on the institution’s operations. In clinical practice, some medical personnel violate the law because they do not fully understand administrative rules and the boundaries of criminal liability. Common types of violations and their legal risks are summarized below:

Type of violation Characteristics Legal risk How it is treated in practice
Allowing unqualified persons to practice Assigning medical secretaries to night shifts, or having unqualified persons give injections or draw blood. Constitutes complicity under Article 28 of the Physicians Act and fraud. The physician in charge is found to be a “co-principal,” and administrative staff also bear criminal liability; the consequences go beyond administrative fines.
Fabricating medical visits (multiple card swipes / misuse of personal data) Swiping a patient’s card multiple times when collecting refill prescriptions, or using relatives’ and friends’ personal data to fabricate records right after opening a clinic. Violates the Personal Data Protection Act; fraud and making false entries in business records. Defendants who deny the offense have been sentenced at first instance to one year’s imprisonment, not commutable to a fine. Administratively, several times the fees are deducted; criminally, it is fraud. Even small amounts carry the risk of a criminal record.
Splitting prescriptions Dispensing within the clinic while reporting the prescriptions as released to a pharmacy to split pharmacy fees. Treated as “aggravated fraud.” The physician in charge and administrative staff have both been sentenced to imprisonment. Undermines the separation of prescribing and dispensing. Courts have held it unlawful even where the physician claimed it was for patients’ convenience.
Billing self-paid items to the NHI Claiming self-paid items such as orthokeratology lenses under diagnoses such as conjunctivitis. Obtaining benefits through improper conduct; fines of up to 20 times the amount, with retroactive recovery. Inspectors estimate total claims by sampling ratios and apply the “five-year limitation period for unjust enrichment under public law” to recover payments going back five years.
Operating under a borrowed license A nominal physician does not actually see patients, while unlicensed persons run the clinic. Involves practicing under another’s name; offenses are counted per month and the prison sentences combined. The nominal physician in charge cannot escape liability by claiming merely to have “rented out the license,” and still bears full administrative and criminal liability.

The National Health Insurance Administration has established big-data monitoring mechanisms, including reports from former employees, cross-checks for unusual geographic relationships between clinics and pharmacies, and complaints filed by the public through the “NHI Express” app. The inspection process usually involves interviews with patients, on-site inspections, and interviews with medical personnel. Interview records become important evidence in later judicial proceedings. When interviewed, medical personnel should check the contents carefully, avoid omitting important details under the pressure of the clinic setting, and sign only after verifying the interview record.

〔照片 2〕

Key Points of the “Self-Correction” Mechanism

  • Report before an inspection: discover and report irregularities before the National Health Insurance Administration or prosecutors and investigators begin a formal inspection or interview patients.
  • Explain candidly: describe the actual circumstances of the improper claims.
  • Repay the fees: voluntarily return the improperly obtained fees.
  • Voluntary self-correction and settlement: there is a relatively high chance of receiving a deferred prosecution from the prosecutor.
  • No self-correction (case concluded after investigation): the rate of deferred prosecution drops sharply.

Analysis of Article 81 of the National Health Insurance Act

Executive Director Chou Hsien-Chang went on to give an in-depth analysis of the provision in Article 81 of the National Health Insurance Act that “where criminal liability is involved, the case shall be transferred to the judicial authorities.”

Clearing Up Misconceptions

Misconception 1: An employed physician who files claims as instructed by the employer is exempt from liability?
Explanation: If an employed physician knows that the claimed items do not match the actual medical services (such as billing self-paid items to the NHI) and still cooperates by issuing diagnoses, the law may find “indirect intent to commit fraud” and treat the physician as a co-principal. The physician cannot escape liability merely by being an employee.

Misconception 2: “Collecting medication on a patient’s behalf without the patient entering the consulting room” is only an administrative lapse?
Explanation: If there was genuine medical care but the physician did not personally examine the patient, the administrative consequence is a deduction of several times the fees. But if a disease diagnosis is fabricated in order to claim consultation fees, it falls within criminal fraud.

Compliance SOP

  • Examine patients in person: strictly observe the principle of personal examination, and never swipe cards or split prescriptions without seeing the patient.
  • Conduct regular internal audits: use NHI-related systems to check internal claim records, and pay attention to rules on drug price differences.
  • Seek joint-management support: if claim errors are found, contact the medical association for guidance and start the self-correction process before any formal inspection by the National Health Insurance Administration.

Compliance in NHI claims is part of the everyday risk management of medical institutions. At the institutional level, the Taipei Medical Association provides guidance through its joint-management mechanism to help medical personnel clarify procedures; at the same time, fees voluntarily returned through self-correction flow back into the medical global budget for redistribution, helping keep overall point values stable.

At the individual and institutional level, raising awareness of legal compliance helps reduce legal risks in practice. Continued cross-disciplinary exchange between medicine and law helps establish clear boundaries of conduct, so that the medical profession and a sound NHI system can be maintained within a compliant framework.

Further Reading

  • 【20250513 Law vs. Medicine: Strengthening Medical Record Management and Legal Awareness】
  • 【20250722 Law vs. Medicine: Freedom and Regulation of Medical Practice—Legality of Prepaid Fees】

This English version was prepared with the assistance of AI. Please refer to the Chinese text for accuracy.


Zusammenfassung 

【20250909 Justiz vs. Medizin: Betrug in der nationalen Krankenversicherung – häufige Fälle unzulässiger Abrechnung erkennen】

Am 9. September 2025 fand ein medizinrechtlicher Vortrag der Reihe „Justiz vs. Medizin“, die nun in ihr drittes Jahr geht, in den neuen Räumen der Taipei Medical Association statt. Veranstalter waren die Chung-Hua Institution for Legal Research (die Stiftung), die Taipei Medical Association und die Chinese Society of Law. Unter der Moderation des Stiftungsvorsitzenden Dr. Chou Nai-Kuan schilderte Präsident Chen Tsung-Chen von der Chinese Society of Law die hohe Belastung der Justiz durch Betrugsverfahren. Anschließend wurden die Haftung nach Art. 81 des Gesetzes über die nationale Krankenversicherung und die wichtigsten Formen unzulässiger Abrechnung erläutert. Dazu gehören die Beschäftigung unqualifizierter Personen, fingierte Behandlungen, das Aufteilen von Verordnungen und die Abrechnung von Selbstzahlerleistungen über die Krankenversicherung. Behandelt wurden außerdem das Prüfverfahren, die Möglichkeit der Selbstanzeige, verbreitete Irrtümer und eine Compliance-Checkliste für medizinische Einrichtungen.

Diese Zusammenfassung wurde mit Unterstützung von KI erstellt. Maßgeblich ist der chinesische Text.


要約

【20250909 司法vs.医療:健康保険詐欺――不適切な保険請求の典型例を見分ける】

2025年9月9日、3年目を迎えた「司法vs.医療」講座の医事法講座が、台北市医師公会の新会館で開かれました。主催は財団法人中華法学研究院(本法人)、台北市医師公会、中華法学会です。本法人の周迺寬董事長が司会を務めました。中華法学会の陳宗鎮理事長は、司法機関が抱える詐欺事件の負担の重さについて述べました。続いて、全民健康保険法第81条に基づく責任と、健保署が重点的に摘発する不適切請求の類型を解説しました。具体的には、無資格者による医療行為、架空の受診記録、処方せんの分割、自費診療の保険請求などが挙げられました。さらに、調査の流れ、「自主申告」の仕組み、よくある誤解、医療機関向けのコンプライアンス手順も紹介しました。

本要約は AI の支援を受けて作成したものです。正確な内容については中国語の本文をご参照ください。

Font Size
Share