【20261109 Law vs. Medicine: Legal Risks Every Primary Care Physician Should Know】
Overview
On November 9, 2026, the Taipei Medical Association and the Chung-Hua Institution for Legal Research (the Foundation) held the fourth medical-law seminar in the “Law vs. Medicine” lunchtime series. The Foundation is sincerely grateful to the Chinese Society of Law for its support as co-organizer. This seminar was also the final session of the 2026 series.
The topic was “Legal Risks Every Primary Care Physician Should Know.” Distinguished Chair Professor Chen Tsung-Fu of the College of Law, National Taiwan University, was invited as the speaker. The Foundation was deeply honored that Dr. Chou Hsien-chang, Executive Director of the Taipei Medical Association and Convener of its Primary Care Committee, graciously agreed to serve as discussant. The moderator was Dr. Nai-Kuan Chou, Chairperson of the Foundation, serving in his capacity as Convener of the Taipei Medical Association’s Medical Affairs and Legal System Committee.
Seeing patients, filing claims and running a clinic can all involve legal issues for primary care physicians. Covering AI in medicine, outsourced testing and staffing, informed consent and National Health Insurance (NHI) claims, the seminar introduced participants to the legal risks commonly found in medical practice.
The key points are summarized below. Members of the two organizing bodies are welcome to consult the full handouts and video recording.
Opening Remarks
Dr. Nai-Kuan Chou, Chairperson of the Foundation, opened with remarks expressing his hope for continued exchange between the medical and legal communities. Dr. Yu Chong-Jen, President of the Taipei Medical Association, noted that medical practice is becoming increasingly diverse and that practitioners greatly need concrete advice from legal experts. He also congratulated Professor Chen Tsung-Fu on his recent appointment to the National Chair Professorship. Wu Ming-Tzu, President of the Foundation, expressed her hope that participants would gain practical medical and legal knowledge in a relaxed setting.
After the remarks, the Taipei Medical Association presented certificates of appreciation to President Wu Ming-Tzu, Distinguished Chair Professor Chen Tsung-Fu and Executive Director Chou Hsien-chang, and the distinguished guests posed for a group photo.
Key Points of the Lecture
Professor Chen began by sharing that while preparing the talk, he had asked an AI tool about the topic. The AI claimed that the answer came from Professor Chen himself, which served as a reminder that AI answers still need careful verification. He made three main points.
1. Risks that AI in medicine brings to primary care institutions
Professor Chen noted that at this stage AI remains an assistive tool, and physicians still bear responsibility for final decisions and oversight. Whether a physician blindly follows or rejects an AI’s assessment, the legal standard remains the level of care expected of a reasonably qualified and diligent physician. Informing patients in advance that AI is being used does not by itself relieve the physician of liability. When using public AI tools, physicians should avoid entering any personal data that could directly or indirectly identify a patient.
2. Liability for outsourced testing and staffing
Professor Chen illustrated this point with two cases, one involving an error in genetic testing and one involving outsourced hospital staff. A medical institution that entrusts testing, specimen transport or staffing to others is not thereby relieved of liability. When outsourced personnel make mistakes while working within the institution, the institution may also be held jointly liable.
3. Informed consent
Professor Chen explained that the physician bears the burden of proving that the duty to inform and explain has been fulfilled. It is therefore advisable to record these explanations in detail in medical and nursing records. He also introduced the courts’ views on informed consent in criminal cases.
Discussant’s Remarks
Speaking on “Standards for Referring Improper NHI Claims to Judicial Authorities,” Dr. Chou Hsien-chang explained that on May 24, 2023, the National Health Insurance Administration issued guidelines under Article 81 of the National Health Insurance Act on referring cases to judicial authorities. Under this tiered approach, minor or unintentional violations are handled through administrative measures. Only serious cases are referred for prosecution, with criminal penalties as a last resort.
Referral to judicial authorities applies to five types of conduct:
- harboring unlicensed medical practitioners;
- providing items that are not medically necessary;
- fabricating medical services;
- filing claims under another person’s identity;
- repeat offenses.
Dr. Chou reminded physicians to check medical records before filing, to file claims only for services actually provided, and to correct any errors they find on their own initiative.
Open Discussion
During the open discussion, participants on site and online asked about situations common in primary care clinics, such as informed consent and family members collecting medication on a patient’s behalf. Both speakers answered each question.
Conclusion
Held on the eve of Physicians’ Day, this seminar brought the 2026 “Law vs. Medicine” lunchtime series to a successful close. Legal risks are often hidden in the everyday practice of primary care physicians. Understanding what the law requires allows physicians to care for their patients while also protecting themselves.
For more on AI in medicine, medical records, NHI claims and informed consent, please see these earlier seminars in the “Law vs. Medicine” series:
- AI-Assisted Diagnosis: Legal Liability and Risk Management in Clinical Decision-Making (August 4, 2026)
- Strengthening Medical Record Management and Legal Awareness (May 13, 2025)
- NHI Fraud: Identifying Common Types of Improper NHI Claims (September 9, 2025)
This English version was prepared with the assistance of AI. Please refer to the Chinese text for accuracy.
Zusammenfassung
Justiz vs. Medizin: Rechtliche Risiken für niedergelassene Ärztinnen und Ärzte (9. November 2026)
Am 9. November 2026 veranstalteten die Taipei Medical Association und die Chung-Hua Institution for Legal Research (die Stiftung) das vierte medizinrechtliche Mittagsseminar der Reihe „Justiz vs. Medizin“. Es war zugleich die letzte Veranstaltung der Reihe im Jahr 2026. Die Stiftung dankt der Chinese Society of Law herzlich für ihre Unterstützung als Mitveranstalterin. Es referierte Prof. Chen Tsung-Fu von der juristischen Fakultät der National Taiwan University. Als Diskutant wirkte freundlicherweise Dr. Chou Hsien-chang von der Taipei Medical Association mit.
Prof. Chen betonte, dass KI derzeit nur ein Hilfsmittel sei und die letzte Entscheidung sowie die Aufsicht bei der Ärztin oder dem Arzt verblieben. Zudem seien Medizinische Einrichtungen auch bei ausgelagerten Labor- und Personalleistungen nicht von der Haftung befreit, und die Beweislast für die ordnungsgemäße Aufklärung liege bei der Ärzteschaft. Dr. Chou erläuterte die seit 2023 geltenden Grundsätze, nach denen nur schwerwiegende Fälle unzulässiger Abrechnungen bei der Krankenversicherung an die Justiz weitergeleitet werden. Die Veranstaltung endete mit einer Fragerunde.
Diese Zusammenfassung wurde mit Unterstützung von KI erstellt. Maßgeblich ist der chinesische Text.
要約
司法vs.医療:開業医が見落としてはならない医事法上のリスク(2026年11月9日)
2026年11月9日、台北市医師公会と財団法人中華法学研究院(以下「本法人」)は、「司法vs.医療ランチタイム講座」医事法シリーズ第4回を開催しました。本講座は2026年度シリーズの最終回となりました。協力団体としてご支援いただいた中華法学会に、心より感謝申し上げます。台湾大学法学院の陳聰富講座教授を講師にお招きし、台北市医師公会の周賢章常務理事にコメンテーターをお引き受けいただきました。
陳教授は、AIは現段階ではあくまで補助的なツールであり、最終的な判断と監督の責任は医師にあると述べました。また、検査や人員を外部に委託しても医療機関の責任は免れないこと、説明義務を果たしたことの立証責任は医師にあることを説明しました。周常務理事は、2023年に定められた原則により、健康保険の不当請求のうち重大な事案のみが司法機関に移送されることを紹介しました。講座の最後には質疑応答が行われました。
本要約は AI の支援を受けて作成したものです。正確な内容については中国語の本文をご参照ください。